Kings and Princes, They Come and Go

Minority students offer their perspectives on the 2024 Presidential election and the incoming Trump administration.

In the days leading up to the 2024 Presidential Election, junior Annabelle Romero heard many jokes around campus but didn’t feel like laughing. 

As a third-generation Puerto Rican student, she wanted her peers and classmates to see that her identity wasn’t a punchline. After comedian Tony Hinchcliffe called Puerto Rico an “island of floating garbage” at the Oct. 28 Trump rally in Madison Square Garden, she noticed similar comments around campus increasing. According to Romero, these insensitive jokes usually referenced immigration and deportation.

Romero, an anthropology major minoring in studio art, was disappointed but not surprised. She believes that this disrespectful comment is not an isolated instance but is tethered to America’s long history of racism. 

Although Romero said she usually avoids conflict, the recent election caused her to start more conversations. Knowing several stories of friends and family at risk of deportation, Romero saw her choice to vote for Harris as an obligation to honor those she loved.

“Women fought for the right to vote for so long. I want to respect that — I come from this history,” she said. 

While Romero leaned more Democratic, Karla Rocha, a Latina sophomore majoring in psychology with a minor in international relations and a pre-law certificate, differed. 

She, too, held immigration as a top issue and would have cast her vote for Trump-Vance. However, she cited Texas’ short window for turning in ballot applications as the reason she did not vote.

Rocha is from Laredo, Texas, a border city to Mexico, where much of the political conversation veered toward desires for stronger border control to prevent potential violent cartel activities, she said. With Trump being the only presidential candidate who made a stop on the campaign trail in her city, Rocha felt like his stronger border policy would benefit her city compared to the Harris-Walz campaign. 

Additionally, she wasn’t happy with Harris’ past as a prosecutor with high levels of Black incarceration. 

“I feel like that’s a lot of what people forgot,” she said. 

Alani Oyola ’24, who graduated with a degree in English writing and urban studies, similarly believed her identity as a mixed Puerto Rican and Black woman was at stake in this election. She cited Donald Trump’s anti-immigrant rhetoric as the main reason.  

“I come from two families that have a history of immigration to the US,” she said. “They’ve always encouraged me to embrace the civil liberties and rights that I have as an American citizen.”

Although Oyola voted for Harris-Walz, she wasn’t happy with 100% of the policies within either campaign. What it ultimately came down to, she said, were their policies regarding gender, sexuality and recent ethnic relations. Even so, she didn’t hesitate to critique the Biden-Harris administration. 

Specifically, Oyola believed the Biden-Harris campaign had been hesitant in calling the conflict in Israel and Gaza a “genocide,” which she perceived as creating a narrative of overall “Democratic disinterest” and hurt the party as a whole, she said. 

The hardest thing for Oyola was not choosing between voting for Trump or Harris but rather whether she would withhold her vote in the hopes that the demand for a ceasefire in Gaza would be heard.

“I was not perceiving Harris and Walz to be the saving grace of America, and I can and do recognize a lot of the faults of the Democratic Party,” she said.

The run up to the 2024 presidential election saw varying levels of support from different Latino groups. According to a pre-election analysis of polling data conducted by the Americas Society/Council of the Americas, 59 percent of Puerto Ricans said they supported Harris, while Mexican-Americans had a slightly higher level of support at 62 percent. Those with their country of origin being in South America were close at 53 percent. 

The disaggregated exit polling data is in contrast to the overall Latino vote, according to NBC, which shows overall support for Trump near 46 percent, with Latino men at 54 percent. While specific Latino communities did lean Democrat, a record number of Latino voters supported Trump in this election. 

Rosa Kader, who works for Bon Appetit’s food service at Wheaton and is from Mexico City, shares Rocha’s desire for stronger border control. For her brother to come to the United States, it took 17 years to enter legally. Kader felt relieved to see a Trump victory for stronger immigration enforcement, hoping that middle-class, tax-paying immigrants legally going through the citizenship process might be prioritized rather than refugees.  

“A country without borders is not a country. If I go to Mexico, I have to show proof that I’m a citizen of them,” Kader said. 

Graphic by Kristen Baurain.

Sam Lopez Pecarina, a Latino sophomore majoring in international relations with a minor in Latin-American Studies, and the Unidad Cristiana social media manager, said that negative attitudes toward immigrants made him feel less safe on campus following the election results. 

“I just know that things will change, at the very least in the public mindset, which will make this anti-immigrant attitude more into the legislature,” he said. “We see them by their papers and not by their souls.”

Lopez Pecarina said an additional concern was that humanitarian immigrant-serving organizations like World Relief, where he hopes to intern, may face struggles under the future Trump presidency. 

“They’ve been planning layoffs since November,” he said, referencing how the agency is anticipating similar cuts in federal funding as in 2017 under the last Trump administration. World Relief cut a fifth of its staff due to Trump’s capping of refugee admissions.

Rickie Gray, a Black junior majoring in urban studies and the president of the Willie Osborne Society, also shared his worries. Having voted for Harris, Gray feared a negative aftermath on campus following the election, and he was saddened to hear the potential political motivation behind the recent Kilby house vandalism incident.

Gray said his younger sisters were at the forefront of his mind as he researched and cast his vote, and they were whom he said he was scared for. 

“Reproductive rights were a big thing on the table this election, and I don’t know what that looks like for my sisters in the future,” he said.

Lauren Chang, a Korean senior majoring in biology and the President of Koinonia, was frustrated with how some of her peers at Wheaton approached thinking about the election, with many of them expressing that there was one correct “Christian” choice. She expressed that the campus environment is unique in that though students share the same core theological beliefs, they often can come to very different conclusions on the same topic. 

She voted for Harris-Walz out of a desire to consider the needs of her community alongside her own. However, she found that no single candidate offered complete solutions to issues she cares about affecting women, people of color and students. 

“It’s hard to distill every problem we face into a series of markings on a ballot,” she said. 

Micah Perry, a Black junior majoring in biology, and the vice president of the Willie Osborne Society, was concerned about the meaning of another Trump presidency for women who are victims of sexual misconduct. She voted for Harris and was also hurt by some Trump supporters’ negative rhetoric toward women and people of color leading up to and after the election. 

Perry is also concerned about students in the wake of the next Trump presidency, with her worries including threats to the Department of Education, book banning, and school shootings. Knowing God is in control, she said, is what allows her to have hope while acknowledging “the current state of things.”

Of all Black voters, NBC showed 92% of women and 77% of men voted for Harris with 86% of Black voters voting for Harris overall. 

Chaplain Angulus Wilson expressed his constant desire to do what Perry had described: see God’s sovereignty through big cultural moments. 

“Kings and princes, they come and go,” he said. “But the king of kings is always ruling, no matter who’s in the White House or on the throne in some nation.”

Wilson seeks to arrange the chapel schedule so that the holistic needs of students are met. One way his office does this is by supporting events put on by the Office of Multicultural Development (OMD). 

David Cho, the director of the OMD, said their mission is represented by a triangle with scripture-based faith at the bottom, race on one side, and ethnicity on the other. He hopes the office can equip students with the tools they need to process the election and world events for the rest of their lives.

Building on the commitment of the OMD, Wilson attributed two chapel talks — one before the election and one after — as a means to give students the tools they need to address their feelings in the context of “cultural divides.”

“I’m looking at the newspaper in one hand and my Bible in the other,” he said. “The kingdom agenda is more needed now than ever before.”

Picture of Kara Grace Hess

Kara Grace Hess

Kara-Grace Hess is a junior studying anthropology, Spanish & HNGR (Human Needs Global Resources) from Nashville, Tenn. You'll usually find her drinking matcha, in the pool and/or working on her next story.

All Posts
Share Post: